Eldercare housing crisis looming

May 24, 2011

Ben Reznik

We are getting older and living longer. The statistics for the growth of the elderly are compelling. In the past few years we have seen several types of new private eldercare facilities, such as independent living and assisted living pop up in the LA area, mostly in more affluent neighborhoods. But make no mistake: neither LA nor the rest of the nation is prepared to properly care for and house the emerging elderly population.

When I speak with people who now must find some level of assisted housing for their elderly parents, their frustration is all too common and similar: there are too few choices and none that are located in their neighborhood. What an interesting concept - siting eldercare facilities "in our neighborhood." This notion is not just for the convenience of the adult child, who wants to remain close enough to the parent for visitation purposes, it is also important for the elder parent, who should not be relegated to living out the rest of his/her life in institutional facilities along major commercial corridors. There must be a way to integrate eldercare housing into residential neighborhoods, including single-family areas.

In 2006, the City of Los Angeles adopted an Eldercare Ordinance (178,063) which tackled this issue head on. It specifically provides for the siting of such facilities in virtually all zones, including single family zones, through a process that enables a public hearing and the imposition of conditions. One of the biggest issues confronting eldercare facilities in the past has been the amount of parking that should be required. This ordinance modified the parking requirement to more closely prefect the actual parking need, thereby eliminating the need for complicated variance hearings. This ordinance would not have passed but for the tireless work of then Chief Zoning Administrator Robert Janovici, who realized its importance and shepherded it through the legislative process.

Now comes implementation. Will the city approve such facilities if faced with local neighborhood opposition? There have only been a couple of applications utilizing the Eldercare Ordinance so the answer is yet unknown. However, recently the Tarzana Neighborhood Council demonstrated strong leadership on this issue when it voted to recommend approval of an assisted living facility in one of its residential neighborhoods. Many of the Neighborhood Council members pointed out that it is our responsibility as a society to house the elderly in the very same neighborhoods in which they had lived for many years, rather than succumb to the pressure of forcing them to live in commercial areas. In a sense, what the Tarzana Neighborhood Council is saying is that while the care of the elderly may be a business, the housing is residential in character.

It will be interesting to see how the City deals with this case as it makes its way through the process.





ben reznik cropped.jpgBen Reznik is the founder and chair of the Government, Land Use, Environment and Energy Department at Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell LLP. Ben's practice emphasizes real estate development entitlements, zoning and environmental issues. He appears regularly before planning commissions, city councils and other governmental boards and agencies, as well as the courts. Ben and his work have been featured in the Los Angeles Times and the Los Angeles Business Journal, and he has been included in the Los Angeles Daily Journal as one of California's "Top 100" lawyers. Ben leads a group of distinguished attorneys whose work has resulted in JMBM's inclusion in the U.S. News & World Report / Best Lawyers® list of Best Law Firms (2011-2012) with a National First-Tier Ranking and a Metropolitan First-Tier Ranking (Los Angeles) in the area of Land Use and Zoning Law. Contact Ben at BMR@jmbm.com or 310.201.3572.